Choosing the right dog crate can make all the difference in your pet’s safety, comfort, and well-being. Among the most popular crate options are plastic and aluminum crates. While both types offer distinct advantages, they cater to different needs and situations.

In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of plastic and aluminum crates to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re looking for a crate for travel, home use, or managing an anxious or strong dog, this guide will help you pick the right one.

Plastic Dog Crates: Pros and Cons

Advantages of Plastic Dog Crates

1. Great for Travel
   
   • Most plastic crates meet airline regulations for cargo travel.
     
   • They often come with secure doors and reinforced frames.
     
2. Enclosed Space for Comfort
   
   • The solid sides give dogs a den-like feel, making them feel safe and secure.
     
   • Ideal for dogs that get anxious when too exposed.
     
3. Lightweight and Easy to Transport
   
   • Made from durable yet lightweight plastic.
     
   • Equipped with handles for easy carrying.
     
4. Quiet and Low Noise
   
   • Unlike wire crates, plastic crates don’t rattle or make noise when your dog moves.
     
   • Reduces anxiety, especially during travel.
     

Disadvantages of Plastic Dog Crates

1. Limited Ventilation
   
   • Fewer ventilation holes compared to aluminum or wire crates.
     
   • Can become hot and stuffy, especially in warm climates.
     
2. Less Durable
   
   • While sturdy, they are prone to cracking or breaking if heavily chewed or dropped.
     
   • Not suitable for strong or aggressive chewers.
     
3. Difficult to Clean
   
   • Non-removable bottom trays make thorough cleaning challenging.
     
   • Odors can linger if not cleaned properly.
     
4. Limited Visibility
   
   • Dogs that prefer to see their surroundings may feel confined and stressed.
     

Best Uses for Plastic Dog Crates

• Air Travel: Meets IATA requirements for most airlines.
  
• Low-Energy Dogs: Ideal for calm dogs that prefer a cozy space.
  
• Home Use: Suitable for smaller dogs or those that don’t chew aggressively.
  

Aluminum Dog Crates: Pros and Cons

Advantages of Aluminum Dog Crates

1. Ultimate Durability and Strength
   
   • Made from aircraft-grade aluminum, these crates are practically indestructible.
     
   • Chew-proof and resistant to bending, breaking, and damage.
     
2. Escape-Proof Design
   
   • Heavy-duty latches and tamper-resistant locks ensure even the most determined dogs stay contained.
     
   • Great for breeds prone to escaping or chewing.
     
3. Superior Ventilation
   
   • Perforated panels or bars provide consistent airflow, keeping your dog cool.
     
   • Reduces the risk of overheating, even on long trips.
     
4. Crash-Tested Safety
   
   • Impact Dog Crates, for example, are crash-tested for car travel, offering unmatched safety.
     
   • Keeps your dog secure during road trips and emergencies.
     
5. Easy to Clean
   
   • Smooth, rust-resistant surfaces make cleaning a breeze.
     
   • Removable bottom trays make maintenance simple.
     

Disadvantages of Aluminum Dog Crates

1. Higher Cost
   
   • Aluminum crates are generally more expensive than plastic or wire crates.
     
   • The price reflects the superior build quality and durability.
     
2. Weight
   
   • Heavier than plastic crates, making them less convenient to move around.
     
   • Some models are collapsible for easier transport, but they are still bulkier than plastic.
     
3. Industrial Appearance
   
   • The rugged, metallic look might not fit aesthetically in some homes.
     

Best Uses for Aluminum Dog Crates

• High-Energy or Chewing Dogs: Perfect for powerful breeds prone to breaking out.
  
• Travel Safety: Ideal for road trips where crash protection is essential.
  
• Home and Kennel Use: Suitable for long-term containment and crate training.
  

Plastic vs. Aluminum: A Head-to-Head Comparison

Feature	Plastic Crates	Aluminum Crates
Durability	Moderate – Prone to cracking or chewing	High – Chew-proof and nearly indestructible
Ventilation	Limited – Fewer holes, can get stuffy	Excellent – Perforated sides for constant airflow
Escape Resistance	Low – Clever dogs can chew or break out	Very High – Tamper-proof latches and reinforced
Portability	Lightweight and easy to carry	Heavier, but some are collapsible
Cleaning	Harder to clean, especially the corners	Easy to wipe down and maintain
Noise	Quiet – Little to no rattling	Quiet – Noise-dampening designs available
Cost	Affordable – Typically cheaper	Higher cost, but long-lasting
Best For	Calm or small dogs, air travel	Strong, anxious, or escape-prone dogs

---

Which One is Better for Your Dog?

The answer ultimately depends on your dog’s size, temperament, and lifestyle needs.

Choose Plastic If:

• Your dog is calm and non-destructive.
  
• You primarily need a crate for air travel.
  
• You’re looking for a budget-friendly option.
  
• Your dog prefers a den-like, enclosed space.
  

Choose Aluminum If:

• Your dog is strong, high-energy, or prone to escaping.
  
• You need a crate for road trips or crash-tested safety.
  
• Durability and long-lasting quality are top priorities.
  
• You want a crate that’s easy to clean and maintain.
  

Why Impact Dog Crates Are the Top Choice

When it comes to aluminum crates, Impact Dog Crates set the standard for quality and durability. Built with aircraft-grade aluminum, they are designed to withstand the strength and determination of even the most aggressive chewers.

Key Features of Impact Dog Crates:

• Crash-Tested Safety: Ideal for both home use and travel.
  
• Heavy-Duty Locks: Prevents breakouts and tampering.
  
• Excellent Ventilation: Keeps dogs cool and reduces stress.
  
• Noise Reduction: Minimizes rattling and vibrations.
  
• Lifetime Warranty: Built to last and endure heavy use.
  

Real-Life Story: Diesel the Pit Bull

Diesel, a powerful Pit Bull with a history of breaking out of plastic and wire crates, found safety and comfort in an Impact Dog Crate. After multiple failed attempts with cheaper models, his owner finally invested in a High Anxiety Impact Dog Crate. Diesel remained safe, secure, and stress-free—even during long road trips.

Final Thoughts: Quality Matters

While plastic crates are practical for some situations, they simply don’t match the strength, security, and durability of aluminum crates. If your dog is a strong chewer, escape artist, or anxious traveler, investing in a high-quality Impact Dog Crate is the best way to keep your pet safe and comfortable.

Choose wisely—your dog deserves a crate that meets their needs and keeps them secure in every situation.